A different road: my journey beyond the biomedical model

For years Ivan was told his pain was purely biological – a life sentence of medication. Only through talking therapy did he discover the truth: healing meant understanding his story, not just treating his brain.
‘Is there anybody going to listen to my story all about the “demon” who came to stay?’ (Lennon/McCartney – Girl, Rubber Soul)

Ivan Hochberg
social worker • 60s • victoria

This is a heartfelt account of my struggle with childhood demons that followed me into adulthood – leading to an existence marked for years by torment, fear, sadness, and unhappiness. It was a world I would never wish upon anyone, a world where, at times, ending my life felt like the only real escape from unbearable pain.

In the early 1990s, I began to feel overwhelmed by distress, anxiety, and depression. The demons I had long managed to avoid finally took hold of my psyche; my inner world became one of profound despair. As a trained social worker, I knew I needed help – I was fortunate to personally know a psychiatrist who helped me access the care I needed.

The first road to healing

He referred me to another psychiatrist for psychotherapy – simply talking therapy, nothing more. Over time, through conversation and reflection, we explored how my past was shaping my present. Gradually, I began to heal and experience a quality of life I had never believed possible. In time, the therapy came to a natural and appropriate close.

The label that confined me

But after a period of stability, I began to slip again. The demons had returned. When I went back to my psychiatrist, he seemed puzzled by the change and, rather than exploring it in depth, appeared to conclude that I was experiencing a biological depression. He prescribed medication, and as I started to ‘improve’ over the following months, that diagnosis became my defining label.

For years, I cycled through emotional decline and partial recovery. My psychiatrist adjusted my medication, and life oscillated between misery, brief relief, and occasional happiness. I lived under the shadow of a ‘biological illness,’ believing there was little else I could do but comply and accept that this was my reality. I trusted his expertise.

A different kind of doctor

When my psychiatrist retired, I sought another – someone to help manage my medication for the inevitable downturns of what I still believed to be a biological condition. This new psychiatrist was also a psychotherapist and suggested returning to talking therapy. I hesitated – wasn’t my condition simply a reflection of my biology? However, I agreed to begin therapy, as I recognised I was once again slipping into another deep, extended depression.

Learning to live with the demons

Through this renewed exploration, I began to better understand my inner world and what in my past was contributing to my current distress. Slowly, I learned how to live with and respond to the demons. There were still difficult moments, but I could meet them with awareness and a growing sense of control rather than fear.

Talking therapy alone achieved this – with only intermittent use of medication during periods of acute crisis. The medication, at times, dulled my feelings enough for me to face what lay beneath them. Gradually, my life became my own. I was no longer defined by depression. I could accept and value who I was.

That journey took several years, but it enabled me to achieve a more sustained contentment.

A story I recognised in others

As my own life became more stable, I found myself able to share some of my experience with family members and friends. They in turn felt encouraged to talk about their own struggles, and I learned that they too had, on occasions, descended into various levels of darkness – a darkness I knew all too well.

Many described a similar pathway. They first approached their GP seeking help. Medication was often recommended, followed by a mental health care plan that may have included a limited number of sessions with a psychologist. When they found they were not getting any better in the short-term, they were referred to a psychiatrist who, after an initial consultation, suggested augmenting treatment with changed or additional medications – and when that was not working, a course of neuromodulation: either transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) or, in extreme cases, electroconvulsive therapy (ECT). Most had come to understand, as the professionals had explained to them, that their struggles were fundamentally associated with a brain disorder.

I recognised in their accounts the same anguish and unhappiness I had felt when told that my condition was predominantly biological – an approach that left me confined, defined, and adrift, having to live forever with emotional pain. Rarely had any of my family or friends encountered a medical professional who wanted to engage with their full human experience – to understand them as a person, or to explore the inner world contributing to their pain.

What recovery actually looks like

When I read media accounts of recovery from psychological and emotional struggle – predominantly celebrities sharing their stories – I rarely hear gratitude directed toward medication or physical treatments provided. More often, there is acknowledgement of a person: someone who listened, who engaged, and who helped them find a path through their pain.

The story that needs to change

It appears that the biomedical model continues to dominate treatment and has become the cultural gold standard for managing personal, psychological, and emotional distress. This has been the story for so many of us – repeated attempts to treat with medications and physical interventions such as TMS or ECT, and yet we continue to struggle with our pain. These treatments are of limited value when offered alone as a primary treatment.

My writing this is not anti-medicine nor anti-psychiatry. I continue to see a psychiatrist when I need to – one who has resisted a purely biomedical approach, despite pressure from many of his peers to practise differently. It is my attempt, and my wish, to show that there is another road that can be travelled; one that provides more effective treatment, better care, and – most importantly – hope.

This is the story I want you and others to listen to.

 

Share Your Story

Your experience
matters to this work

If you’ve experienced unwanted or excessive medicalisation of emotional distress — medication side effects, difficult withdrawal, or being misunderstood by the system — we invite you to share your story.

Every account helps us understand how widespread these issues are and strengthens the case for systemic change.